Better Than the Movies by Lynn Painter

Liz Buxbaum has always thought her neighbor Wes Bennett was the worst—definitely not boyfriend material. But when her longtime crush, Michael, moves back to town, Liz realizes she needs Wes’s help to get his attention. As they team up, Liz is surprised to find herself actually enjoying Wes’s company. Soon, she begins to question what love really looks like—and whether her perfect prom date might not be the boy she always imagined.